Imply maid_apron to maid

BUR #26285 is pending approval.

create implication maid_apron -> maid

Since this is one of the main elements of clothing.
It can be worn in case of Enmaided, but that tag already autotags as maid.

tbh the maid apron tag is a bit shit, since people just tag it on any pic of a maid wearing an apron where waist apron more than suffices

im in favor of nuking it entirely since any change to its requirements would just be mistagged

Adding to this despite erroneous usage maid apron is a specific syle of apron and should not just be apron + maid. post #7567641 is one for instance

I am also in favor of nuking.

zetsubousensei said:

Adding to this despite erroneous usage maid spron is a specific syle of apron and should not just be apron + maid. post #7567641 is one for instance

Is there a difference between that and frilled apron?

gfz said:

I am also in favor of nuking.

Is there a difference between that and frilled apron?

It doesn't need to have frills, while common, post #7080623 shows a maid apron without them.

I guess I'm missing what actually makes it a maid apron then. Is it something about the material or the shape?

Changed my vote from meh to downvote. Aside from agreeing with a couple of posts against this BUR, what happens in cases of maid_apron nude? Maid doesn't apply because a maid uniform isn't being used but the specific apron being worn is one that would normally be worn as part of the maid uniform, and with current tags considered, apron (a bland, every-day apron) wouldn't apply either.

gfz said:

I guess I'm missing what actually makes it a maid apron then. Is it something about the material or the shape?

It's the shape, a maid apron basically looks like a sideless, white pinafore dress with the tie at the waist.

+1 for a nuke, though, because although this should technically be a distinctive tag like witch hat, I think keeping users from not tagging it on any maid wearing any type of apron sounds like a nightmare, and you can still reliably find it using -waist_apron in searches.

Try to search "maid_apron -maid". I've removed made_apron in some posts that are definitely don't have maids. There were only 40 such posts out of 3000 I've watched, but I'm only halfway through the cleanse.
What do you think?

WeakestResUser said:

Maid doesn't apply because a maid uniform isn't being used

maid nude
maid naked_apron

The maid apron that we tag is part of the maid uniform. Its existence by itself is enough to tag maid because you can tell it's obviously a maid.

The fact that some users mistakenly used tag maid_apron to maids with waist_apron is bad, but they are maids. And if we make an implication, we can save a shitton of work. We can always nuke it later

BUR #26287 is pending approval.

mass update maid_apron -> apron maid
nuke maid_apron
deprecate maid_apron

maid apron is currently being used as "any apron worn by a maid", both in practice and in the wiki.
I don't think this will ever change, so I propose we replace it with apron + maid.