To be fair Rider, your pool is very subjective despite the title. They're no perfect guideline to what makes a picture "disgustingly adorable" so you shouldn't blame people for adding it.
Truth be told, it's too real-lookin' to be disgustingly cute. The other pic, that was on the verge of Charmin-bear-"cute", which is disgusting via cute. That fine line between head explosions and vein-popping.
Elmira:: AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW -grabs kitty and squeezes it tightly- I'm gonna take you home and kiss you and hug you and feed you and make love to you lil..... -kitten head explodes-